
Mystery was my first love.
Some of its earliest manifestations were Nancy Drew and Harriet the Spy. As a young girl, I read every classic Nancy Drew novel I could get my hands on. Nancy was perky, brave, and resourceful and it didn’t hurt that she was often accompanied by the handsome and capable Ned. Harriet, on the other hand, could be a bit judgmental, but she was a precocious and spunky sleuth. Both Harriet and Nancy had me convinced that there was some great curiosity to investigate, intrigue around the next corner, excitement bubbling beneath the surface. I dreamed of great adventures, mysteries to solve, and like Harriet, I kept my own secret notebook of my observations. What I usually found, however, was rather mundane and definitely not mysterious. Disappointing, to say the least.
Enter Edisto Island, South Carolina. Edisto is one of the great gifts of my childhood, a bastion of mystery itself. There are no neon lights, chain restaurants, or boardwalks on Edisto. Ancient Live Oak trees line the main road onto the island; their limbs forming spooky tunnels covered in green vines and draped in Spanish moss. Gullah culture still survives in the homes with blue trim around the windows and doors, keeping the evil spirits at bay. Snippets of their distinctive Anglo-Creole language can still be heard at the Piggly Wiggly, the one grocery store on the island. If you drive by Botany Bay Road you will see the aptly named, “mystery tree.” A lone, skinny tree standing in the middle of the marsh that some unknown person honors with seasonal decorations (think ornaments at Christmas and flags for the Fourth of July.) Drive a little further toward the beach and you will pass the mattress swing, hung from chains under a tree. There may be children or dogs resting on top. And then, of course, there is the Atlantic ocean itself, vast and gray and tumultuous.
My grandparents had a beach front house on Edisto and I had the great privilege of spending long weeks there as a child with my family. We were bathed in brine, baked by the sun, covered in sand like sugar, and lulled to sleep by the ocean every night.
Enter Columbia Theological Seminary. After many years of vocational wandering it finally occurred to me that faith had always been the most important part of my life and seminary might be a good place to go. And it was. I became more of who I always wanted to be. I learned ancient languages. I became a preacher. I administered sacraments. I debated ethical issues. I surveyed the Old and New Testaments. I became an exegete. I wrote way too many papers. I practiced my skills in internships. I went to Mexico. I passed big, long exams. But most importantly of all, I was steeped in mystery. From day one of Greek School there truly were mysteries to be investigated in the next word, on the next page, or in the next conversation. I loved almost every minute of it (“Ministry Through the Year” was a huge exception).
Over time I found myself less concerned with the “right” answers and more and more in love with the Mystery. I wanted my whole life to be a sacrament (my seminary friends will remember that sacrament is a Latin translation of the Greek word mysterion, “mystery.” How appropriate!), a visible sign of God’s invisible grace. I prayed to be in over my head with God and all that Divine power and love.
Okay, what in the world does all this have to do with gnats?
Enter Edisto Island again, last week actually. Although my grandparents are no longer living and the beach front house was destroyed by Hurricane Tammie several years ago, we try to go to Edisto at least once a year. I was especially excited about this trip because it would be Gabe’s first experience of the beach and my parents and sister would be joining us for part of the week. My mom and I decided to take Gabe for a walk on one of those evenings when the air is thick and humid and electrified. Tropical Storm Fay was approaching and bands of dark clouds were forming out over the ocean. We talked as we walked and we noticed that every so often we would be slapping at bugs, eventually realizing that swarms of tiny gnats seemed to congregate at regular intervals along our path. As annoying as this was we also began to see small, dark birds flying over our heads in erratic patterns. Mom said, “Look at all these swallows! I don’t think I’ve ever seen this many at one time.” And of course, it finally dawned on both of us that the swallows were eating the gnats. We stopped in amazement as those sleek, black birds darted all around and above us. I once again felt the thrill of being part of something much bigger than myself, caught up in the mysterious ways of Nature, which was actually intervening on our behalf.
I’ve thought much about the swallows and gnats since our return from Edisto and it seems to me that wanting to embody mystery is asking for trouble. How can there be mystery without some interplay between dark and light? To experience the swallows so dramatically we had to be among the gnats. As I think back on the many enchanted childhood days on Edisto, in addition to the magic there were also lots of mosquito bites, more than the occasional cockroach, and painful sunburns. The holy sacraments we celebrate consist of very ordinary bread, water, and wine. The mysteries are, by design it seems, quite mundane. Perhaps this is instructive for me as I struggle with suburbia, the daily routine of caring for a 10-month old, and a marriage stretching into that seven-year itch. Is the Spirit present? Will God do for me what only God can? Is there yet something bubbling beneath the surface?
